| YEAR |
WINNER |
LOSER |
SCORE |
SITE |
| 2010 |
New England |
Oakland |
50-47 |
Fairfield, CT |
| 2009 |
Oakland |
Philadelphia |
43-29 |
Philadelphia, PA |
| 2008 |
Miami |
San Francisco |
54-21 |
San Francisco, CA |
| 2007 |
Oakland |
Arizona |
47-44 |
Oakland, CA* |
| 2006 |
Arizona |
New England |
43-25 |
Phoenix, AZ |
| 2005 |
New England |
Baltimore |
24-19 |
Baltimore, MD |
| 2004 |
Baltimore |
New England |
45-42 |
Baltimore, MD |
| 2003 |
Baltimore |
Jacksonville |
30-18 |
Baltimore, MD |
| 2002 |
Jacksonville |
New England |
43-20 |
Jacksonville, FL |
| 2001 |
New England |
Baltimore |
56-44 |
Fairfield, CT |
| 2000 |
New England |
Buffalo |
54-43 |
Fairfield, CT |
| 1999^ |
Baltimore Jacksonville |
Denver New England |
34-12 37-27 |
Baltimore, MD Fairfield, CT |
| 1998^ |
Dallas Baltimore |
Jacksonville San Francisco |
33-22 41-26 |
Irving, TX San Francisco, CA |
| 1997^ |
Baltimore Philadelphia |
Jacksonville Denver |
47-24 47-35 |
Jacksonville, FL Philadelphia, PA |
| 1996^ |
Philadelphia Jacksonville |
Toronto Dallas |
29-19 20-10 |
Philadelphia, PA Jacksonville, FL |