| YEAR |
WINNER |
LOSER |
SCORE |
SITE |
| 2010 |
New England Oakland |
Miami Washington |
37-34 39-28 |
Fairfield, CT* Oakland, CA |
| 2009 |
Oakland Philadelphia |
Washington Miami |
33-21 27-24 |
Spokane, WA Miami, FL |
| 2008 |
Miami San Francisco |
Washington New England |
49-39 39-28 |
Spokane, WA Fairfield, CT |
| 2007 |
Oakland Arizona |
Washington Miami |
29-22 32-24 |
Oakland, CA Miami, FL |
| 2006 |
New England Arizona |
Oakland Buffalo |
51-38 41-36 |
Oakland, CA Orchard Park, NY |
| 2005 |
Baltimore New England |
Buffalo Miami |
35-14 43-12 |
Orchard Park, NY Miami, FL |
| 2004 |
Baltimore New England |
Jacksonville Buffalo |
38-21 33-26 |
Baltimore, MD Orchard Park, NY |
| 2003 |
Jacksonville Baltimore |
Philadelphia Pittsburgh |
43-42 51-32 |
Philadelphia, PA Baltimore, MD |
| 2002 |
New England Jacksonville |
Baltimore Mississauga |
47-29 59-44 |
Baltimore, MD Mississuaga, ON |
| 2001 |
New England Baltimore |
Jacksonville Philadelphia |
57-47 38-33 |
Jacksonville, FL Philadelphia, PA |
| 2000 |
Buffalo New England |
Miami Jacksonville |
53-23 93-45 |
Miami, FL Fairfield, CT |
| 1999^ |
Denver Jacksonville |
Pittsburgh Dallas |
52-27 37-28 |
Denver, CO Jacksonville, FL |
| 1998^ |
Jacksonville Baltimore |
Oakland San Diego |
29-26 23-21 |
Oakland, CA Baltimore, MD |
| 1997^ |
Denver Baltimore |
New England Toronto |
37-34 30-16 |
Denver, CO Baltimore, MD |